Key Colony Beach 1st Add Homes for Sale

Key Colony Beach 1st Add Homes for Sale

Welcome to Key Colony Beach 1st Add., a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Monroe County, Florida. This charming subdivision is situated in the picturesque city of Key Colony Beach, known for its stunning coastal views and laid-back island lifestyle. Here, residents enjoy the perfect blend of tranquility and recreation, making it an ideal destination for those seeking a slice of paradise.

Key Colony Beach 1st Add. boasts a variety of homes for sale, each offering unique architectural styles and modern amenities. From quaint beach cottages to luxurious waterfront estates, there’s something to suit every taste and budget. Many of these homes feature spacious layouts, expansive outdoor living spaces, and breathtaking views of the sparkling Atlantic Ocean or serene canals. Imagine waking up to the sound of gentle waves and enjoying your morning coffee on a sun-kissed patio.

Living in Key Colony Beach means embracing an active lifestyle. Residents are just a stone's throw away from pristine beaches, world-class fishing, and a myriad of water sports. The community also offers a range of amenities, including parks, golf courses, and dining options that cater to every palate. Whether you’re a seasoned angler or a beach lover, this vibrant community has something for everyone.

With homes for sale in Key Colony Beach 1st Add., now is the perfect time to invest in your dream coastal retreat. Experience the charm of island living and make this enchanting community your new home. Don't miss out on the opportunity to own a piece of paradise in one of Florida's most desirable locations!

Newest Key Colony Beach 1st Add Homes for Sale

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ A12063553 MLS

Waterfront retreat in Key Colony Beach with direct ocean access and no fixed bridges. Featuring a private dock, boat lift, and jacuzzi, this home is perfect for boating, fishing, and embracing the Florida Keys lifestyle. Bright, inviting interior with seamless indoor-outdoor living, just minutes from beaches, waterfront dining, golf, and local attractions. Ideal as a primary home, vacation getaway, or investment opportunity.

160 10th Street, Key Colony Beach

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ A11959094 MLS

Turnkey, fully furnished waterfront property with strong Airbnb income history. Enjoy 37.5 ft of dockage with unrestricted ocean access and a quick 5-minute ride to the Gulf and ocean side. Home sits above flood, helping reduce insurance and overhead. Features include a 2017 roof and a new water heater (2025). A rare opportunity for investors or buyers seeking effortless coastal living.

410 10th Street, Key Colony Beach

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ A11963904 MLS

Welcome to this 2-bedroom waterfront home in Key Colony Beach offering direct canal frontage and classic island appeal. Built in 1961 and updated, this one story half duplex blends low maintenance living with functional waterfront access.Interior highlights include tile flooring throughout, ceiling fans, window treatments, and a comfortable layout with two full bathrooms and well proportioned bedrooms across approximately 952 square feet. Home Constructed using CBS (Concrete block & Stucco) for durability.Waterfront and exterior features:• Direct canal frontage with seawall• Screened porch for outdoor dining• Approximately 4,125 sq ft lot• One car garage• Paver driveway• Off street and guest parking• Front side impact windows/ Back Accordion shutters• Monitored security• 40ft Boat Dock (Seawall has permit and is being redone in April 2026)Ideal for boating enthusiasts seeking convenient canal access in Key Colony Beach. Located in Monroe County near local dining, marinas, and island amenities, this property offers an opportunity to enjoy the Florida Keys lifestyle in a manageable waterfront setting.

151 10th Street, Key Colony Beach

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B26028132 MLS

Welcome to Key Colony Beach, where life slows down and waterfront living feels effortless. This east facing canal front half duplex offers 37.5 ft of deep water dockage with quick access to both the Atlantic Ocean and Florida Bay through Vaca Cut. Wake up to peaceful canal views, enjoy your morning coffee from the balcony, and spend your days boating, fishing, or relaxing under the lanai. The flexible owner's lockout adds excellent income potential while maintaining your private retreat. Located close to Sunset Park, golf, tennis, pickleball, restaurants and with access to the Cabana Club's oceanfront pool, beach, and restaurant. Just a short drive from Marathon's private aviation hub at MillionAir.

180 9th Street, Key Colony Beach

Start Your Search

Laura Auten - Broker

Learn More

Dan Tyrie - Real Estate Advisor

Dan has called South Florida home since 1985, with deep roots in Palm Beach County. He began his real estate career in 2013 and brings a wealth of related experience to the table—not only as a licensed real estate professional, but also as a successful entrepreneur. Dan has built and sold both a real estate photography company and a property management business. These ventures have given him a unique, well-rounded perspective on the industry, allowing him to offer clients comprehensive guidance throughout every step of their real estate journey. Dan is known for his approachable style, strategic insight, and unwavering commitment to helping others achieve their real estate goals. Whether you're buying, selling, or investing, Dan is the kind of trusted advisor you want in your corner. Outside of work, Dan enjoys a full and active life with his girlfriend, their three growing boys, and a charismatic French Bulldog, named Chip. While parenting provides daily purpose and joy, Chip often steals the spotlight with his endless antics. An avid lover of the outdoors and live music, Dan can often be found boating along the intracoastal and hanging out at the local sandbars, biking the local trails, or catching his favorite bands in concert. He’s also a seasoned snowboarder and makes regular trips to Steamboat Springs, Colorado—a place that holds a special place in his heart from his early twenties.

Learn More